-
Posts
1,150 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Everything posted by ifishy
-
the steel head are still suffering from that large die off several years back there are not a lot of fish in the lake more than 6 years old but with the cleaner water fish have to swim faster and farthur when feeding so there is some slimming in profile as well. this is really visable in steal head. for the brown there are still some pigs out there and they feed heavy on goby at times iI cant say there is as many as there was 5 or 6 years ago but the brown population in the lake is very heavy and with big fish at the top end for sure. its possible that there may be other tecniques that would better target those large ones in the current lake conditions and trolling just does not get as many of the slobs but that is pure speculation
-
Chinook daemon spawn once and die period they can mature early or wait an extra year there is always some variety in the age they spawn at that is normal variation meaning one catastrophic weather event wont make a population go extinct (hopefully) fore lake o when they started the majority ran the river when they were 3.5 yeas old so 3 full summers of growth over the years a growing percentage is maturing and spawning at 2.5 so one less summer of growth it might be that our hatcheries are less accessible to larger fish it might be that the areas that have natural reproduction are more accessible to smaller younger fish it may be that larger fish are targeted successfully by steam fisherman it could be that an extra year in the lake makes them more likely to be caught and kept it is probably a combination of those and other factors
-
with kings size is also partly a function of age. over the years a larger and larger percentage of Lake O fish are running at 2 years old instead of 3 and very few are holding out that extra year. the fact is that likely has its advantages in Lake O which is why its become more prevalent. the kings here now have been both artificially and naturally selected for better survival in lake Ontario under current conditions. the fact that we have notable if inconsistent natural reproduction speaks to that. new genetics would likely be far less advantageous and to get them established in the population would be significantly harder in time and cost than just adding some new eggs and any introductions would likely be gone within a couple generations. The fact is that lake Ontario is not the same as it used to be it is a changing and evolving ecosystem and it may not be able to have as many 30+lb fish. We also tend to have selective memory. 40lb fish happened but it was not an every year occurrence. Good hatches of alewives do not mean good year classes if recruitment is low. so if we had 3 large year classes as of this year than this years stockers would be the first to have access to that there whole life so we would see the size increase 2 years from now. the fact is the numbers in the lake of 2 year olds seems to be really high this year and is likely caused by good recruitment of natural fish due to increased bait abundance. The DEC has done a good job of using real data and science to manage the fishery and they have taken input from stake holders on what outcomes to target. Its easy to say things like they are small make them bigger but thats not how it works. I do think there could be some merit in running a multi year experiment to selectively pull older/larger fish for crossing and than tagging the young to see if they start to have a disproportionate representation in derbys or creates a small sub set of the population that goes 3 and even 4 years in the lake. It could be done on a small scale within the current stocking strategy and provide the data needed to determine if its worthwhile to try on a larger scale.
-
Unusual Condition off of Ibay
ifishy replied to Sea Lion's topic in New York Fishing Reports - Lake Ontario (South Shore)
Sk8man nailed it some of my local creeks have washed out higher than I have ever Seen recently and those flows can ball up all sorts of crap worth checking out as it can pull bait In but not worth working hard good areas to work with aggressive tactics to find the "spot on the spot" a washed out creek dumping debris for a day can create miles of this set up -
Black Biting Flies while trolling on Lake Ontario
ifishy replied to A-TOM-MIK's topic in Open Lake Discussion
-
For fish or for food? I use a 60qt (I think) for fish on derby days it's the right size for lake o
-
Inside #5 with weight in first hole outside #4 with weight in 3rd hole all wire divers I also use a longer heavier rod on the outside it runs well
- 1 reply
-
- 1
-
-
These days fish are often more boat shy stick with 2 riggers with the smaller boat (my opinion) there is a lot of really good info about rigging on this site when I got back I to trolling g this site cut years off the learning curve and I still pick up great tips and info here
-
Gambler is right we are at the north end of the range for shad. There is always someone winter kill it actual an important feeding time for catfish. That said a mild winter can cause a population boom which leads to a larger kill I'm later years if it all or mostly shad it's a good thing its normal cycle and means the lake could produce that much life in the fist place
-
Consider what your goal is long lines catch fish but the longer the harder catch and release becomes. Long junk lines tend to be increased work and decreased fun. My boat only runs them for derbies. The 4 diver set up is good advice for sure I will say this though with a smaller aluminum when I run 4 divers I do not do cheater on the down riggers I find with kings the extra lure is almost guaranteed to get into a diver line and almost always around one and into the other so 4 dipseys no cheater 2 dipseys cheater is okay. I use a 1 and 3 setting with a size 5 chinook inside and a size 4 for the high diver. Also weighted steel is much more user-friendly than copper so that's my recomendation
-
Downrigger Backlash
ifishy replied to Just1skipper2's topic in Questions About Trout & Salmon Trolling?
It's not necessary to see them on your sonar but the more blow back the more they are in the way of other lines and netting its really about comfort -
Sandy 5/27
ifishy replied to ShawnJ's topic in New York Fishing Reports - Lake Ontario (South Shore)
We're your marks east or west gonna be that way tomorrow but haven't been on the lake In a couple weeks nice to have a starting point last time I fished there was 3 years ago and I blew my engine haven had a chance with the new boat yet -
Pultneyville
ifishy replied to john1947's topic in New York Fishing Reports - Lake Ontario (South Shore)
Haven't been there in two weeks back than best screens were 30 50 fow west of pultneyvill tried all the way out to 150 with nothing went shallow and went 1 for 2 I the last hour with a big drop back steely. It's old info but weather has been relatively stable I would Starr shallow and slowly work out till I saw marks that area has always been feast or famine for me but we did hit some 2 year old kings out of sodus already this year so good sign for an early set up -
Why not much trash talk about the Seneca Trout Derby?
ifishy replied to Sk8man's topic in Finger Lakes Discussion
-
Why not much trash talk about the Seneca Trout Derby?
ifishy replied to Sk8man's topic in Finger Lakes Discussion
-
Net Pen in 130 ft of water N of Oswego, trollers beware
ifishy replied to schreckstoff's topic in Open Lake Discussion
These discussions can be fun there are a lot of knowledgeable experienced people on this site with varied backgrounds Yankee and gambler are two that know there fishing deserve to be listened to and considered thoughtfully even if you don't agree and consider who starred this thread love seeing comments from the biologist we rely on To keep the lake healthy -
Looking for recommendations on having a Bimini top made
ifishy replied to Henry D's topic in This Old Boat
You can get stock biminis online for less but if you go custom and are willing to pay I recommend a wrap around of some sort stock Biminis come in many heights and lengths so can get whatever size you need that way sport tops or enclosures are a lot harder to find so if paying for custom worth getting the full set up -
Why not much trash talk about the Seneca Trout Derby?
ifishy replied to Sk8man's topic in Finger Lakes Discussion
The derby itself can be a lot of fun and the lake is accessible to boats of all sizes this derby was part of me getting back into trout and salmon trolling on my first boat (14 footer) I fished it 8 straight years and unfortunately in 2018 ad a rough experience (life issues not the derby fault) that combined with a tough fishing year pushed me away I am now looking to get back in just unfortunately busy this weekend this year I always used to think I was only an ok fisherman based on internet reports but I have 3 of those plaques on the wall and mostly good memory's from seneca -
Net Pen in 130 ft of water N of Oswego, trollers beware
ifishy replied to schreckstoff's topic in Open Lake Discussion
The bloater experiment is relatively small stocking primarily on the east half of the lake I wouldn't expect to them be common on the west end in fish that primarily move west to east through the season if the do establish it might create a situation where more kings winter to the east and we more often have good spring king fishing to get valid data it has to go at least a couple full life cycles I would much rather see money spent o. This than on Atlantics which will never be more than a minor bonus fishery -
Net Pen in 130 ft of water N of Oswego, trollers beware
ifishy replied to schreckstoff's topic in Open Lake Discussion
Very well said I agree that experimenting to see if an additional preyfish can be reestablished could prove beneficial both directly and indirectly to the fishery -
Out of the sun when not in use goes a long way but I'm curious to see what other feedback comes for this always good to know ways to take care of the gear
-
Inline board and release for leadcore with braid
ifishy replied to BRsnow's topic in Questions About Trout & Salmon Trolling?
this year i have been experimenting with the offshore board with a walker bullet release on the front. I took the snaps off and used the wire eye to attach it to the board. easy to set easy to release and so far is working better than the sams pro did for me. thinking about trying it on the mag boards for the heavier lines. -
Dec does a ton of walleye stocking around the state typically they try to manage lakes as either warm water or cold water so either trout or walleye and its not because some lakes can't handle both its because resources like hatchery space people and money are not unlimited and government is not efficient with funds realistically there are trout and walleye fishery available within a reasonable drive for everyone in the state including some world class options. They do an excellent job using actual science to make decisions and not just politics and complaining fisherman. The dec gets a lot of crap that isn't justified and the legal system of new york does not take conservation law seriously enough and despite that the state has multiple destination waters for salmon. Bass trout walleye and muskie for those who like other fish the state has some of the biggest sheepshead and carp on the planet
-
Maybe not invasive but there are still disease issues and I know of no known captive population to breed or raise them from would just take to much space that said an aggressive harvest plan to reduce lake trout for a few years might do that lake a lot of Good another option might be to capture quarantine and than release some large Lakers from elsewhere they will happily turn cannabilist which could limit the overpopulation and make a trophy fishery
-
I don't need any more incentive to retire just 25 years more savings