Seneca or Cayuga. My best combo's for some lake trout action this time of year have been:
1. Trolling about 1.5 mph
2. Running in 70-110 feet of water
3. Running my tackle about 10 feet off the bottom
4. Running green flasher/green fly combo with fly 18" off back of flasher
5. Also had good success with cowbells and spinning "popcorn" type rig.
I have had no action on sticks or spoons since the Spring. Now sure what I'm doing wrong there but I have been doing very good with the above setup.
Running in this "shallow" depth of 70-110 feet should produce lots of action. You will probably have to go deeper to catch bigger fish right now but action is what you are looking for and you'll probably do better in this range. Two weeks ago, I used this setup on Cayuga and caught 10 lakers in 3 1/2 hours fishing by myself.
If you plan on coming out to Cayuga I'd be happy to join you and help you out. If you do, send me a PM.
Wayne