Looks like everybody is trying to copy ReefRunners........ The only bait you need.
Seriously, for Browns, does it really matter? Hell, we've caught them on cigarette butts at Slater creek in the past.
I know your talking spring browns here, but the propwash is the ONLY place to catch tigers too! Troll fast, like 5mph and let out about 15' of line and hold on tight!
When they say "snagged" I think they used it figuratively, not literally. Back then they said " we snagged one" for every fish caught in the mouth. I remember hearing about the Seneca river fish.
Just my $ .02.
Since your right in Webster and only have time for a one day trip, you can't beat Sodus Bay, some nice fish come out of there every year, plus it's close by you!