I was out there yesterday at daylight and it started out super slow. Tons of boat traffic and everyone on the radio was saying how slow it was. Marking tons of fish but apparently they were a little spooked by the boat traffic or not feeding. We stuck it out and around noon were were marking tons of bait and lots of good size fish. From noon to about 4 all of us stayed pretty busy with fish and clearing the rods. Like Skipper asked if you had a probe. After using one I would never go back to guestimating again. So handy and tells you your two most important things; speep and temp at your lures. sounds like you guys are on the right track though. Every time I go out I learn something new. One thing though, I know if I hooked that fish on the spinny and fly I would look for my next closest thing to what it hit. Like everyone says "the fish will tell you what they like" Change colors,speed, sizes, depths, and experiment a little with whats working and whats not.