Cayuta creek is about a 15min drive from Watkins Glen. I've never fished it, but I pass it frequently traveling between Canandaigua and Binghamton. It does look like a nice trout stream and I'm pretty sure its open to fishing year round. Or you could throw some lures off the rocks at the Marina park in Watkins. I threw some lures in Geneva last week and hooked up on my third cast. Spit the hook, but it felt like a landlocked. Did land a decent pike though. Sent from my LGMP260 using Tapatalk