Broadhead reviews

Legacy · October 13, 2014

The last few seasons i have shot Slick Trick 1" standards. I am currently shooting 100 grain slick trick 1 1/8" magnums. I made the switch to maintain the same arrow flight but a bit bigger cutting diameter. http://www.slicktrick.net/

Im looking for " the grass is greener" broadhead recommendations?

whaler1 · October 13, 2014

I like G5 striker 100 grains

Sent from my iPhone using Lake Ontario United

apb · October 13, 2014

Not sure how you can beat a muzzy!

Sent from my iPhone using Lake Ontario United mobile app

Bosun Cowboy · October 13, 2014

Nothing compares to a Muzzy 100.

Gill-T · October 13, 2014

Previously I was reluctant to move to expandables, however, I have been using the Grim Reaper three blade the last few seasons and like the penetration I am getting.

salmonite · October 13, 2014

Nothing greener! Stick with the best there is and they are cheap

Sent from my iPhone using Lake Ontario United mobile app

ontherise · October 13, 2014

How about G5's?

Sent from my iPhone using Lake Ontario United mobile app

Frogger · October 13, 2014

Dont let the other day get to you and start questioning things, unless theres something really wrong with your setup, and from the looks of things, youve got it going on and know your sh.... about archery and setting up your hunts etc, Personally I would stay with the Slick tricks, at least for this season, you dont want to be second guessing a new broadhead and sighting it in etc. Ive killed some deer with these things, paint buckets being thrown down everywhere when its solid, and a couple of times a little work was involved, rain etc. Everyone has there favorites though so be prepared for a number of different types. Its the one that you feel most comforatble with.

iceman05 · October 13, 2014

Myself and three buddies all shoot rage 2blade and chisel tip and have great results ....now I have another set of friends who only shoot G5 fixed and they have the same results as us.....so I think it really comes down to what you want to shoot and how it shoots for you...I think in today's modern archery all the grass is the same color green

Sent from my iPhone using Lake Ontario United mobile app

Edited October 13, 2014 by iceman05

JakeyBaby · October 13, 2014

NAP Spit Fires all the way! They fly true just like field tips and leave one hell of a trail. 1 3/4 cutting diameter.

JakeyBaby · October 13, 2014

What it looks like on both sides of the deer all the way till you find it. Given a good shot is made, but then again all broadheads should if the placement is correct. ........

Fishin fintastic · October 13, 2014

Put a rage in the cage have Great results !

Total Chaos · October 13, 2014

They all work if you hit them where you're supposed to but for those times I'm off, there's no better confidence boost than knowing I just put a 2 1/2" hole in him with a Rage Extreme chisel tip. I've had some borderline hits that I'm sure with a conventional head I would never have found the deer.

Total Chaos

TileMan Dan · October 14, 2014

Agree with what Iceman stated. My personal favorite is a 100 gr Muzzy. Shot placement is always first.

Sent from my iPhone using Lake Ontario United

Nautitroller · October 14, 2014

I have been a licensed tracker for deer for 7 years now. My dog and I average about 20-30 tracks a year. My opinion of expandables is: throw them out! They fail in flight, they fail in regards to penetration when they hit any part of the front shoulder. If you want to shoot em with an expandable through the guts wait twelve hours and call me we will find em. Lol! Go with fixed blades and make sure they are super super sharp! Check em for sharpness especially going in and out of your quiver. Good luck guys hope no one has to use us but we track day or night. Pm me if you need my number.

Sent from my C771 using Lake Ontario United mobile app

vrundtjr150 · October 14, 2014

Dead ringer rampage 2 blade

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I747 using Lake Ontario United mobile app

TileMan Dan · October 14, 2014

I have been a licensed tracker for deer for 7 years now. My dog and I average about 20-30 tracks a year. My opinion of expandables is: throw them out! They fail in flight, they fail in regards to penetration when they hit any part of the front shoulder. If you want to shoot em with an expandable through the guts wait twelve hours and call me we will find em. Lol! Go with fixed blades and make sure they are super super sharp! Check em for sharpness especially going in and out of your quiver. Good luck guys hope no one has to use us but we track day or night. Pm me if you need my number.

Sent from my C771 using Lake Ontario United mobile app

I find this quite interesting.

Sent from my iPhone using Lake Ontario United

Nontypical · October 14, 2014

Ramcat 3 blade really puts em for a serious dirt nap!

whaler1 · October 14, 2014

Me too! We use expandables for turkey only.

Sent from my iPhone using Lake Ontario United

PeltHunter · October 14, 2014

I shoot the rage 3 blade 1.5 inch. I like the rage because they give you the practice tips so you can get the same flight and really dial in your sights. With the fixed blades I had even with the same grain field points they wouldn't shoot the same. I shot a buck 2 years ago with the rage and had a huge exit wound. The doe I shot sunday had a good exit wound but only one blade expanded. Double lung and corner of heart so it didn't really matter but it's kind of alarming at the same time. As someone said it all comes down to shot placement in the end.

Sent from my iPhone using Lake Ontario United

Capt Vince Pierleoni · October 14, 2014

G-5 Striker fixed 100 gr. Its the exit hole that matters most besides shot placement. If broadhead choice was for someone on the lower poundage draw weight I would look at the Magnus Stinger "Knife blade", as once again, its about getting through.

zackblain · October 14, 2014

I shoot the 1 3/8'' grim reapers out of my 60# hoyt maxxis 35 and have no complaints so far. They shoot identical to field points and penetration has been excellent. I shot the 2'' grim reaper white tail specials last year and had had one not pass through on a 20 yard shot on a buck last year that was quartering away, the arrow opened up and failed to exit through the opposite shoulder, the buck went down in less than 30 yards but that was enough for me to go to a smaller diameter, gotta have some power for the larger broad heads in my opinion.

this years doe with a 1 3/8 reaper, 20 yards broad side, ran 40 yards and piled up

PeltHunter · October 14, 2014

Pretty good exit on the rage punched through but the arrow didn't exit on a quartering to shot at 17 yards

Sent from my iPhone using Lake Ontario United

Playin Hookey · October 14, 2014

I switched to slick tricks from muzzle and will not shoot anything else. Slick tricks work great out of my Strother sx1 at 67 lbs I am getting about 325 ft per sec. They fly true out to 80 yards may be farther. Have used them for two years now and they are great.

FISH ON

dvdegeorge · October 14, 2014

The last few seasons i have shot Slick Trick 1" standards. I am currently shooting 100 grain slick trick 1 1/8" magnums. I made the switch to maintain the same arrow flight but a bit bigger cutting diameter. http://www.slicktrick.net/

Im looking for " the grass is greener" broadhead recommendations?

You are already in the greenest grass

Sign In

Recent Topics

Sponsored Links Your Ad Here

HOT Topics

Quick Links

New York State Fishing

SIGN UP TODAY

Upcoming Events

Broadhead reviews

Recommended Posts

Legacy

whaler1

apb

Bosun Cowboy

Gill-T

salmonite

ontherise

Frogger

iceman05

JakeyBaby

JakeyBaby

Fishin fintastic

Total Chaos

TileMan Dan

Nautitroller

vrundtjr150

TileMan Dan

Nontypical

whaler1

PeltHunter

Capt Vince Pierleoni

zackblain

PeltHunter

Playin Hookey

dvdegeorge

Create an account or sign in to comment

Create an account

Sign in