Jump to content

Onondaga lake?

Bluefin54
 Share

Recommended Posts

old man

old man

Posted
Posted

Not personally but i know a guy who does. He says the north is best for tigers. I've seen some pics of some that looked mid thirties.

Sent from my iPhone using Lake Ontario United

315angler

315angler

Posted
Posted

I haven't fished there for them but know of some big ones that have been caught. You can google some old ones from Syracuse.com.

Sent from my iPhone using Lake Ontario United

muskiedreams

muskiedreams

Posted
Posted

I think I have heard that there are a lot of walleye there too. The problem is you don't want to eat them out of that lake. At one time, I believe it was considered the most polluted freshwater lake in the country. They are still working on removing all the pollutants from the bottom of the lake. I believe they they sill don't allow swimming in the lake. But I have heard that the fishing is good there for various species. You just don't want to eat them.

Ronix 51

Ronix 51

Posted
Posted

I fished it for tigers a few years ago. There are certain points in the year where fish will stack up in the Seneca river mouth and I'm sure a ton of tigers do too. They stocked 10,000 3 years ago and have been stocking that portion of the Seneca river for a while now so they are definitely in there. North end is your best bet the south end is very turbid and void of structure.

Cuse

Cuse

Posted
Posted

How'd you do out there? 

 

I fish oversized bass lures over deeper weeds (usually 12-15ft) on grass lines and catch a couple mid 30's northerns every trip and a handful of tigers throughout the year. I actually find more tigers in the river, but catch them in the lake too. Biggest tiger I've got out there was only 36" but I've had follows from much bigger (I'm usually fishing for bass). I have caught northerns up to 40" in there. It's a real fun place to fish but there was 10x the pressure out there this year (I'm assuming from the articles in the paper talking it up this year). There's some big healthy fish in there, obviously no eating, however I have seen reports that walleye tagged there have been pulled out of Oneida...

muskiedreams

muskiedreams

Posted
Posted

 There's some big healthy fish in there, obviously no eating, however I have seen reports that walleye tagged there have been pulled out of Oneida...

The distance is reasonable so it is not surprising. I imaging they could also go to many other locations through the canals but they would have to be very adventurous.

justtracytrolling

justtracytrolling

Posted
Posted

Walleye fishing is good there, but honestly what's the point? They aren't sportfish and you literally cant eat em....lets go recreate in the worst possible water available....there's world class xander fishing in chernobyl too if you are interested (im serious) its only 20 min tops from there to otisco and im pretty sure there are more and bigger tigers in otisco...and if you get water on you it isnt harmful!

MeatHunter737

MeatHunter737

Posted
Posted

That's exactly why I've been interested in otisco. I've eaten a ton of eyes from onieda and it makes me wonder. Time to figure out another body of water....

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I537 using Lake Ontario United mobile app

Cuse

Cuse

Posted
Posted (edited)

Walleye fishing is good there, but honestly what's the point? They aren't sportfish and you literally cant eat em....lets go recreate in the worst possible water available....there's world class xander fishing in chernobyl too if you are interested (im serious) its only 20 min tops from there to otisco and im pretty sure there are more and bigger tigers in otisco...and if you get water on you it isnt harmful!

 

I agree, I don't think anyone is suggesting targeting walleye there. Same for for the tigers - I don't target them there, just a good by catch. I enjoy Onondaga for the good bass fishing and best pike fishing in CNY - I've always liked fishing for Northerns. Otisco can be tough in summer months, but it's definitely where I go when I'm targeting tigers. Also the campground launch is about 40 minutes for me but I can have my boat in the water on Onondaga in 15-20 minutes for those shorter 2-3hr trips.

 

I made a 2-3 hr trip this past week on onondaga and caught 6-7 fish including a 5lb 14oz lmb, 3.5lb smallie and a 35" northern, not too many places around here where thats possible.

 

Either way I have a blast at either lake, we're lucky to have such good fishing here.

Edited by Cuse
justtracytrolling

justtracytrolling

Posted
Posted

Great fishing in cny for sure! Onondaga certainly has quality fish as its catch n release in a sense and the bass are solid and from what i hear from my son cooperative. Otisco is tough always, but not for tigers any time the season is open!

Bluefin54

Bluefin54

Posted
  • Author
Posted

I made it out for about 3 hours saturday morning. Casted for about an hour and had a nice tiger, upper 30s maybe 40 follow into a figure 8 but then took off. Switched over to troll for the remainder and picked up a 33" tiger and mid 20s northern.
 
Ran into some SUNY Biology students that had the nets out for walleye, they said they see walleyes in the 8lb range. They also said that they see tigers that migrate in from otisco.. whether that is true or they are just seeing spring spawning behavior in the creeks..

 

post-158192-0-19877400-1442852004_thumb.png

Ivan

Ivan

Posted
Posted

Nice looking tiger. I'd say that was a successful first 3 hours on a new lake.

Sent from my iPhone using Lake Ontario United mobile app

315angler

315angler

Posted
Posted

There are definitely tigers from Otisco in there, they spill over from the dam and go down 9 mile. Tons of tigers in the creek. I saw 6 tigers over 30" in one hole earlier this year and one was in the mid 40s (caught a 36 for reference). Nine mile connects to Onondaga so that is one place they come in from.

Sent from my iPhone using Lake Ontario United

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...